10

What Is The Best Home Gym Machine?

When designing your home gym, it’s important to prioritize what equipment you need to make you gym functional for you. This marcy diamond elitewill be different for all of us and will depend on your fitness level, your goals, space, and of course budget. Investing in a home gym machine can be a smart purchase, but like any other product, not all are created equal. What is the best home gym machine for me? Good question, let’s explore a little and find out.

Do I Need A Home Gym Machine?

First things first, let’s make sure you are in the right place to begin with. If you are reading this, you are probably doing some research because you are interested in getting a home gym for your home (gym). If not, than thanks for visiting, and kindly move on. I’m kidding, even if you don’t know what a home gym is, you can continue reading for the sheer joy and pleasure of reading such a wonderfully written blog…

Ok, back to business. In all seriousness, you need to ask yourself whether you really need this piece of equipment before you commit to purchasing one. If you don’t like lifting weights or resistance training, I don’t suggest you spend your money on a home gym. Home gym machines are designed for resistance training. They are good at this. They are not very good at providing cardio workouts.

It’s always a shame to see a nice piece of equipment sitting in someone’s attic collecting dust. We all have the best of intentions when we purchase them. Maybe it’s right after the holidays and it’s time to get in shape again. Maybe you just saw a motivating infomercial on tv. Or, maybe you just watched Rocky IV again and watching Rocky train in Russia has motivated you to hit the weights. Regardless, before you buy a home gym, or any other workout equipment for that matter, make sure you are going to use it! Don’t waste the money or the floor space by not using your new equipment.

But, if you enjoy lifting weights and you don’t want to worry about finding room to stack free weights or dumbbells, a home gym machine might just be perfect for ya. When you add up the cost of having to accumulate all the different weights or machines, a home gym can actually be a pretty affordable option. Especially if buying one allows you to completely cancel your commercial gym membership.

Different Kinds Of Home Gym

Home gyms very based on what type of resistance they use, as well as the different exercises they allow you to perform. The biggest qualifier though, is the resistance type. Let’s take a quick look and the different types of resistance you can get in your home gym:

  • Weight stack: these are the type of machine you see in commercial gyms. The resistance is provided by a stack of weights and usually a pin system where you can increase or decrease weight by selecting the number of weights in your stack. Weights usually in 5 or 10lb increments. These machines vary in price, but price usually depends on the amount of resistance, the number of exercises available, and the durability of the machine. You can spend $400 – $4000 depending on what your needs are. Most machines offer bench press, lat pull down, maybe leg extensions or hamstring curls. Click here to see the best weight stack home gym systems. 

weight stack

  • Resistance band/rod: no weight stacks here, instead they use bands or rods. Think Bowflex. You increase or decrease resistance by adding more or less rods. This resistance feels a little different than lifting traditional weights, little more fluid. In Bowflex’s case, they suggest this resistance style puts less pressure on the joints. I’m not sure if that is true or not, but the feel of a resistance rod is definitely different. Price also varies in this category, depending again on resistance and number of accessories. Price can easily vary from $500 – $3000. Bowflex is the big name brand in this category.

power rod

  • Free weights: think plates for these home gyms. Barbells, Smith machines, cages. The resistance is added by adding plates to the bar. This is your old school way of lifting. You find these in commercial gyms everywhere. Great for doing bench presses, squats, pull ups. You see some combination machines that have a Smith machine and cage as well as a weight stack and cable system. Prices can range from $500 – $5000 depending on quality, resistance, and accessories.

free weights

  • Body weight: in these systems, your body weight provides all of the resistance. Remember the Total Gym? These machines can be great because they don’t take up much space, there’s no need for weight stacks or plates, and you can get a full body workout by switching between moves rapidly. We use to have a Total Gym in the therapy clinic I worked at, I’m a fan but will discuss these separately in a different post.

body weight

3 Price Ranges

When looking at all the different styles and prices of home gym, it’s difficult to compare them fairly. Comparing a $4000 commercial grade system to a $400 home system is kinda silly. Obviously, the more expensive models are nicer and they cost more for good reason. In an attempt to compare apples to apples and oranges to oranges, I’ve broken up the machines into 3 categories:

  • Under $500
  • $500 – $1000
  • Over $1000

I’m also not going to include the commercial equipment because, after all, this is a website dedicated to exercising in your “home gym”. Most home gyms don’t have the room for the larger, multi-stack machines you see in commercial gyms. If you do have that kind of room and are looking for some recommendations on commercial grade equipment, hit me up with a comment and I will help as much as I can.

Best Home Gym For Under $500

Bowflex PR1000 Home GymBowflex PR1000

Best Price: Click here to check on Amazon!

Type of Resistance: Power Rod

Max Resistance: 210 lb

Warranty: Frame 1-year, parts 60-days, power rods 5-years

Average User Rating: 4.5/5

Footprint: 84″ x 38″ x 82″

Pros

  • Price!
  • 300 lb max user weight
  • 5-210 lb of resistance
  • Provides total body strengthening workout
  • Able to perform 30 different strengthening exercises
  • Includes cardio rowing
  • Durable, high quality construction
  • Solid warranty on power rods
  • Bench folds to save space

Cons

  • Max resistance of 210 lb
  • Some complaints that it doesn’t fit well for tall folks

Bowflex PR1000

Bowflex has been a trusted brand for 30 years and these machines are the cornerstone of their business. The PR1000 is the most affordable home gym model they offer. This home gym machine is perfect for the beginner and intermediate weight lifters. More elite strength trainers will probably max out the resistance in this machine pretty fast. Keep in mind though, that although it only provides 210 lb of max resistance, the power rods have a slightly different feel than free weights and are going to challenge you a little differently.

Especially if your are lifting with slow, controlled movements, which is recommended. That said, for most of us, 210 lb is plenty. This gym allows you to hit all the major muscle groups with plenty of exercise variability. At this price range, the Bowflex PR1000 can’t be beat!

Best Home Gym $500 – $1000

Marcy Diamond Elite Smith System marcy diamond elite

Best Price: Click here to check on Amazon!

Type of Resistance: Free weight

Max Resistance: 600 lb

Warranty: 2-year limited on parts

Average User Rating: 3.9/5

Footprint: 95″ x 79″ x 86″

Pros

  • Commercial grade construction
  • Very stable cage for safety during Smith machine exercises
  • Includes Smith machine!
  • Versatility to perform over 100 exercises
  • Includes high cables for cable cross-overs, tricep press-downs, etc.
  • Attachments included: lat bar, triceps rope, shiver bar, ankle strap, Chrome row handle, 2 single handles
  • 6 Olympic plate storage pegs
  • Easy bench adjustments

Cons

  • Weight plates not included
  • Large footprint
  • No pull up bar
  • Some complaints on assembly instructions

marcy diamond elite

The Marcy Diamond Elite Smith System is the real deal. This is what I picture when I think of a home gym machine. I mean look at this thing. You should be able to complete any strength training exercise you can think of on this piece of equipment. The incorporation of the high cables adds a lot of variety for the lifter. A Smith machine is on my personal wish list, and the Marcy Diamond Elite Smith System offers one plus much more. I would have loved to have seen a pull up bar somewhere on this system, but that’s no biggie. This machine will give you a total body strengthening workout without limitation.

It just squeaked in the price range. If you add the cost of having to purchase the weights I guess it would fall outside of the $1000 ceiling, however this is such a good buy I think its worth it. If you are currently going to the gym to lift weights, you could easily cancel your membership with the purchase of this system. Just an awesome home gym.

Best Home Gym Over $1000

BodyCraft Xpress Pro Home Gym bodycraft press pro home gym

Best Price: Click here to check on Amazon!

Type of Resistance: Weight stack

Max Resistance: 200 lb (up to 400 lb on leg and bench press)

Warranty: Lifetime warranty

Average User Rating: 4.8/5

Footprint: 56.5″ x 83″ x 82.9″

Pros 

  • Pulleys/cables provide fluid, unrestricted movement during exercise
  • Large variety of exercise with adjustable cables- over 100!
  • Offers full body range of strengthening exercises
  • Gym quality weight stack/cable system
  • Durable, high-quality construction of frame and parts
  • Attachments included: lat bar, curl bar, ankle strap, 2 single handles
  • Plenty of resistance with 1:2 cable ratio on bench press (200 lb turns into 400 lb resistance)
  • Lifetime warranty!

Cons

  • Price
  • Leg press attachment sold separately
  • Difficult assembly

The BodyCraft Xpress Pro Home Gym is a beautiful, commercial grade machine. Home gyms that incorporate weight stacks and cable systems tend to be more expensive, and there is no exception to the rule here. With a lifetime warranty though, BodyCraft is definitely backing up their product. This home gym will literally last forever. With the variety of exercises available, there is no getting bored or out growing this product.

This home gym machine will offer you a commercial gym quality workout if the comfort of your home. Just be warned, the biggest complaint I could find was regarding the assembly. Sounds like it takes a long time to put together. Looking at the picture above, I’m not surprised. There are a lot of cables and pulleys…

Will’s Pick

handAll 3 of the home gyms mentioned in this post won my respect, each in their own price range. As mentioned at the beginning of the post, it can be really hard to compare products between price ranges. That said, my personal favorite of the 3 I mentioned would be the Marcy Diamond Elite Smith System.

I’ll be honest, I want a Smith machine! I love that you can do squats, bench press, deadlift, shoulder press all with the same piece of equipment. If space isn’t a factor, I prefer free weights to cables or rods. A thousand bucks for all that the Marcy Diamond Elite offers is a great buy if you ask me.

But when looking at these 3 models, or any other home gyms, consider what your goals are and what type of exercise you want to be doing. These 3 home gyms each have a different form of resistance: power rod, free weights, and weight stack. Weight stacks and power rods tend to be a little more gentle on the joints than free weights. But as you see, the weight stacks tend to be a little more expensive (but there are much more affordable weight stack machines out there, I just think the BodyCraft Xpress Pro is a really nice system).

If you didn’t find the right home gym machine for you here, check out my comprehensive buyer’s guide to find the perfect option for your home.

If you have any questions about these models or any other home gym machines, leave a comment and as always, I’ll get back to you soon.

 

 

 

 

Will

10 Comments

  1. Hi Will, great advice and a great review. I would love to exercise at home but I feel that I do not have the room for such equipment. Do you feel that I could still get a good workout by just using dumbbells, etc alone. Or is using a home gym such as these the way to go? Thanks.

    • Hi Owain, you can definitely get a great workout without a home gym machine. Let’s face it, a lot of people don’t have room for some of this equipment, and that is ok. We have to adapt our home gyms to the space we have available. If space is a factor, you might want to consider a TRX suspension system, takes up very little room and can provide a total body workout. Check out this post for more info: https://the-home-gym.com/is-the-trx-training-kit-the-only-piece-of-equipment-you-need. You can also get a great workout with dumbbells or body weight alone. Let me know if you need any recommendations, I’d be glad to help you set up a workout.

  2. Hi Will, I truly appreciate the depth you dove into to cover this article. I have oftentimes seen the Bowflex advertised on TV, especially as a kid for some reason growing up in Germany. They were super popular.

    It begs the question, however – how does it “stack up” against traditional weight plates? No pun intended.

    Eventually, I will definitely be looking at a home gym and this website will serve as a valuable resource to make my final purchasing decision. Thanks for the information!

    • Hey Michael, yea those Bowflex machines have been around for awhile and are still really popular. The Bowflex can definitely provide enough resistance to build strength and muscle. It feels a little different than traditional free weights or cables, maybe a little more fluid if that makes sense. They are especially good considering the price and their small footprint.

  3. Great information. Thanks. I really needed a breakdown like this to help me decide on what type of equipment would be best for me.

    Is there any kind of all in one type machine like these that offer cardio and strength training? Seems like that would really be the best use of space for me, but I am not sure it even exists…

    If you have any advice or recommendations I would appreciate it.

    • Hey Jamie, good question. I’m not aware of any home gym that includes weights and a separate cardio machine, but that would be an awesome idea. I have a couple of ideas for ya though. If strength training is your primary goal, some of the home gyms include a “cardio row” attachment. The Bowflex model I mentioned does. It’s basically an attachment that lets you row like a rowing machine. Rowing offers a great cardio workout, so this is one option. You have the resistance training for strength, and the row attachment for cardio. You could also get an elliptical type cardio machine that has arm attachments and crank up the resistance. Personally, I think you can get a great cardio workout without equipment if space is an issue. If I had to choose, I would use my available space for strength training equipment, and get my cardio through burpees, running, jumping rope, or some other type of cardio that doesn’t require a machine. I hope this helps.

  4. Great post Will. There a lot of great machines here. Which one would you say is the most popular? Thanks for sharing.

    • Thanks Rob. Most popular…tough call. I would say it’s pretty close between the Bowflex and the Marcy Diamond Elite. I would go with the Bowflex as the most popular model here, because it has a higher average customer rating and it has been reviewed a lot more than the other 2 models. For the price, it really can’t be beat. That said, all that you get with the Marcy, that’s a pretty amazing price as well.

  5. Hi, I am looking for a system that can be stowed away easily , easy on joints, works on entire body but especially building my legs. I had to stop weights a long time ago due to an injury. Which one would fit me best? Thanks

    • hi, if you are looking for a gym that can be stored away, you should consider the body weight gyms. The Total Gym is awesome because there is no assembly required, it’s ready to use right out of the box. It also folds up for easy storage and can easily be rolled into a closet or somewhere out of the way when not being used. It’s also incredibly gentle on your joints, that’s why they are so popular in therapy clinics.

      The Weider is also very portable and foldable- this gym uses cables to add a little resistance which is nice, especially if you are trying to strengthening up those legs. Same thing with the VigorFit, it also gives you the option to add extra resistance with cables and free weights.

      I hope this helps, if you have any other questions let me know.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.